Categories
EFGST

Nested Systems and Hierarchical Organisation

What is part of what? What can the whole do that its components cannot do separately? How much detail do we need to explain what happens?

My latest General Systems Theory paper, Nested Systems and Hierarchical Organisation, explores these questions. It builds on my earlier papers on causal assembly and emergence by distinguishing three kinds of hierarchy.

  • The assembly hierarchy shows how assemblies become parts of larger assemblies.
  • The causal emergence hierarchy follows the new capabilities that arise as components become organised.
  • The epistemic hierarchy reflects how we group and simplify what we know to answer a particular question.

A pumping installation illustrates the difference. The generator, motor and pump are parts of the installation. Once connected with suitable pipework, the installation can deliver water from a particular source to a particular destination. To estimate how long a tank will take to fill, we may only need the delivery rate. If the flow drops unexpectedly, we may need to look at the transfers between components and the conditions in which they are operating. One level of description can therefore encompass several levels of causal emergence.

The paper also considers why assembly pathways can branch, converge or come to an end. Configuration spaces and energy landscapes help explain which arrangements can persist and which changes are possible under particular conditions. Some assemblies can persist for a long time without becoming part of a more complex whole.

Three free course modules accompany the paper. They include plain-English explanations, diagrams, examples and practical exercises.

  1. Nested Systems and the Three Hierarchies
  2. Assembly Pathways and Their Outcomes
  3. Choosing the Level of Explanation

Open-access paper and related work:

https://www.academia.edu/181464813/Nested_Systems_and_Hierarchical_Organisation

https://rational-understanding.com/efgst/#latest

Free course modules:

https://rational-understanding.com/gst-course/#latest

Supported learning is also available through Google Classroom via the ISSS Student SIG. Those in full-time or part-time education are especially encouraged to join. International Society for the Systems Sciences

Leave a Reply